HomeBooksThe Girl on the Train

The Girl on the Train
reviewed.

A blackout drunk, a window seat, and a couple who look perfect from the 8:04 — the commuter thriller that sold over 20 million copies.

★ 4.0
Our rating
2015
Published
Thriller
Genre
2015 The Girl on the Train GT Paula Hawkins
HardcoverPaperbackKindleAudiobook
The verdictA compulsive one-sitting read with one of fiction's boldest unreliable narrators. Not as sharp as Gone Girl, but far more propulsive than most of the imitators that followed both.

What it's about NO SPOILERS

Every morning and evening, Rachel Watson rides the same commuter train past the same row of Victorian houses outside London. From her window she watches one golden couple — she names them 'Jess and Jason' — and builds a fantasy of the perfect life they must lead. It's easier than her own: divorced, unemployed (though she still rides the train so her flatmate won't know), and drinking herself into blackouts.

Then Rachel sees something shocking from the train window — a moment that shatters her fantasy of the couple. Days later, the woman she calls Jess, really Megan Hipwell, is missing. Rachel was in the area that night, drunk, and woke up bloodied with no memory of what happened. She inserts herself into the investigation, certain she knows something vital, if only she could trust her own mind.

Hawkins tells the story through three women — Rachel, Megan, and Anna, the woman Rachel's ex-husband left her for — sliding across timelines until their accounts collide. The gut-punch of the book is Rachel herself: a narrator the police dismiss, the reader doubts, and even she can't believe, stumbling toward a truth someone very close by needs to stay buried.

Is The Girl on the Train worth reading?

Yes — if you want a fast, twisty psychological thriller you'll finish in a weekend, this is one of the most readable the genre ever produced.

Honest caveats: seasoned thriller readers often clock the culprit early, because the suspect pool is small — the twist plays better if you read fast and don't interrogate it. Every character is some shade of miserable or unlikeable, which is intentional but wearing for some. And the three narrators' voices sound fairly similar, so you'll lean on the chapter headings and dates to stay oriented. What elevates it is Rachel — the portrait of alcoholism, memory gaps, and gaslighting is genuinely unsettling and gives the book more weight than its beach-read reputation suggests.

Who it's for

Pick it up if

  • Readers who devoured Gone Girl and want the next unreliable-narrator fix
  • Anyone who loves piecing together a mystery from contradictory accounts
  • Commuters — the premise hits different when you read it on a train
  • Fans of domestic suspense about marriages that look better from outside

Skip it if

  • You guess twists easily and resent a small suspect pool
  • An alcoholic narrator with repeated blackouts sounds frustrating rather than gripping
  • You need characters you'd actually want to have a drink with
  • You've had your fill of post-Gone Girl domestic thrillers

Is there a movie or show? READ IT BEFORE YOU WATCH IT

Yes — the 2016 film directed by Tate Taylor, with Emily Blunt as Rachel. Blunt's performance earned real acclaim (including a BAFTA nomination), though the film moved the story from London commuter land to the New York suburbs and lost some of the book's rain-soaked British atmosphere; critics were lukewarm on the adaptation overall. There's also a 2021 Hindi-language remake on Netflix starring Parineeti Chopra. The book is the better experience — the trick structure of three timelines works best on the page.

If you liked this READ NEXT

2012 Gone Girl GG Gillian Flynn
Thriller

Gone Girl

by Gillian Flynn

The book that built the lane — sharper prose, nastier twist, the natural companion read.

2018 The Woman in the Window WW A.J. Finn
Thriller

The Woman in the Window

by A.J. Finn

Another unreliable watcher — an agoraphobic woman sees a crime through a neighbor's window.

2016 Behind Closed Doors BC B.A. Paris
Thriller

Behind Closed Doors

by B.A. Paris

The perfect-couple facade cranked to nightmare levels — shorter, pulpier, deeply creepy.

Frequently asked questions

Is The Girl on the Train similar to Gone Girl?

They share DNA — unreliable narrators, a missing woman, toxic marriages, shifting timelines — and the book was marketed heavily as 'the next Gone Girl.' The difference: Flynn's book is a colder, more calculated cat-and-mouse game, while Hawkins's is a messier, more emotional mystery driven by a narrator who can't trust her own memory. If you liked one, you'll very likely enjoy the other.

Is The Girl on the Train part of a series?

No, it's a standalone with a fully resolved ending. Paula Hawkins's later thrillers — Into the Water (2017), A Slow Fire Burning (2021), and The Blue Hour (2024) — are all unrelated standalones.

Is the book better than the movie?

Most readers say yes, decisively. Emily Blunt is excellent, but the film relocated the story from London to New York and flattened the three-narrator structure that makes the novel work. The book's slow assembly of Rachel's missing night is much more effective on the page.

Who are the three narrators in The Girl on the Train?

Rachel, the divorced commuter who watches the couple from the train; Megan, the woman who goes missing, narrating events from months earlier; and Anna, who is married to Rachel's ex-husband and lives a few doors from Megan. Their timelines run on different clocks and converge at the night of the disappearance.

A small, excellent email

One good book.
Every single week.

One good book in your inbox every week — picked like this one.