HomeBooksPet Sematary

Pet Sematary
reviewed.

The novel Stephen King thought was too dark to publish — a father, a burial ground, and the worst bargain in horror fiction.

★ 4.1
Our rating
1983
Published
Horror
Genre
1983 Pet Sematary PS Stephen King
HardcoverPaperbackKindleAudiobook
The verdictPet Sematary is King at his bleakest and arguably his most frightening. It's less about monsters than about grief and what it makes people do — which is exactly why it still devastates readers forty years on.

What it's about NO SPOILERS

Dr. Louis Creed moves his young family from Chicago to rural Ludlow, Maine, for a job at the university health center. Their new home sits on a busy road where speeding trucks have killed generations of local pets — which is why the town's children maintain the misspelled 'Pet Sematary' in the woods behind the Creeds' property.

Their elderly neighbor Jud Crandall becomes a second father to Louis, and when the family cat is killed on the road while Louis's daughter is away, Jud shows him what lies beyond the pet cemetery: an older burial ground, once used by the Mi'kmaq, where the soil has a power. What you bury there comes back. It just doesn't come back the same.

The cat's return is unsettling enough — cold, clumsy, smelling of the grave. But the burying ground's true horror is the temptation it plants, because the Creeds live on a dangerous road, and King spends the rest of the novel tightening a dread that every parent will feel in their chest. The question isn't whether tragedy is coming; it's what Louis will do afterward.

Is Pet Sematary worth reading?

Yes — it's consistently ranked among King's two or three scariest books, and it may be the best horror novel ever written about grief.

Be honest with yourself about the content: a child's death is central to the plot, and King refuses every possible comfort — he famously shelved the manuscript for years because he thought it went too far. Some readers find the first half slow, since King spends a long time building the family's ordinary life before breaking it, and the foreshadowing is heavy. But that slow build is what makes the last hundred pages so crushing. Not a book for a fragile week, and parents of young kids should think twice — then probably read it anyway.

Who it's for

Pick it up if

  • Readers who want the scariest single Stephen King novel
  • Fans of horror built on grief, dread, and inevitability
  • Anyone who loved the small-town Maine texture of King's classics
  • Readers who prefer creeping wrongness to splatter

Skip it if

  • Harm to children or animals on the page is a hard line for you
  • You're grieving a recent loss — this book pushes on that bruise
  • You want horror with hope; this one offers almost none
  • Slow domestic build-ups before the scares test your patience

Is there a movie or show? READ IT BEFORE YOU WATCH IT

Yes — twice. The 1989 film, directed by Mary Lambert from King's own screenplay, is a cult classic with an unforgettable Zelda and a chilling Gage; it stays close to the book. The 2019 remake with Jason Clarke and John Lithgow takes a major liberty with which child dies and rewrites the ending, which divided fans. There's also a 2023 prequel, Pet Sematary: Bloodlines. The book is meaner and sadder than any of them — read it first, then watch the 1989 version.

If you liked this READ NEXT

1977 The Shining S Stephen King
Horror

The Shining

by Stephen King

King's other masterpiece of a family destroyed from within — supernatural pressure on human weakness.

1902 The Monkey's Paw MP W.W. Jacobs
Horror

The Monkey's Paw

by W.W. Jacobs

The short story King openly built on: be careful what you wish back from the dead.

2015 A Head Full of Ghosts HF Paul Tremblay
Horror

A Head Full of Ghosts

by Paul Tremblay

Modern horror with the same trick — the family tragedy is scarier than the supernatural explanation.

Frequently asked questions

Is Pet Sematary really Stephen King's scariest book?

King himself has called it the book that scared him the most — he finished the draft, decided it was too dark, and put it in a drawer; it was only published in 1983 to resolve a contract obligation. Whether it beats The Shining or IT is a matter of taste, but no other King novel is so relentlessly bleak.

Why is 'Sematary' spelled wrong?

It's deliberate. The sign in the woods was painted by local children, misspelling and all, and King kept their spelling for the title. The childish lettering over something genuinely ancient and evil is the whole book in miniature.

How different is the book from the movies?

The 1989 film is quite faithful — King wrote the screenplay — though it compresses Louis's slow unraveling. The 2019 remake changes which Creed child is killed and invents a darker, different ending. Neither captures the book's interior dread: Louis's rationalizations are the scariest part, and they only exist on the page.

Does Pet Sematary involve harm to animals and children?

Yes, unavoidably — a cat's death and resurrection drives the first half, and the death of a child is the novel's central event. King treats both with weight rather than exploitation, but it's the reason he almost didn't publish the book. If those are hard limits, this is one to skip.

A small, excellent email

One good book.
Every single week.

One good book in your inbox every week — picked like this one.