HomeBooksMexican Gothic

Mexican Gothic
reviewed.

A glamorous socialite, a decaying English mansion in the Mexican mountains, and a family rot that goes far deeper than the wallpaper — gothic horror with teeth.

★ 4.0
Our rating
2020
Published
Horror
Genre
2020 Mexican Gothic MG Silvia Moreno-Garcia
HardcoverPaperbackKindleAudiobook
The verdictMexican Gothic is a slow-burn gothic that erupts into full-blown body horror in its final act. If you love atmosphere-first horror with a sharp postcolonial edge, this is one of the best of its decade.

What it's about NO SPOILERS

Mexico City, 1950. Noemí Taboada is a chic, quick-witted debutante more interested in parties and anthropology courses than marriage — until her father receives a frantic, half-coherent letter from her newlywed cousin Catalina, who claims her husband's house is poisoning her and that something lives in its walls.

Noemí travels to High Place, the fading mansion of the Doyle family, English silver barons who carved their fortune out of the mountains of Hidalgo. The house is cold, mildewed, and ruled by silence: no smoking, no music, and almost no time alone with Catalina. Patriarch Howard Doyle, ancient and obsessed with eugenics, watches Noemí with unsettling interest, while his son Virgil alternates between menace and charm.

As Noemí digs into the Doyles' history of dead wives and dead miners, her own nights fill with vivid, invasive dreams, and the line between the house's past and her present begins to dissolve. What she finally uncovers beneath High Place transforms the book from moody gothic mystery into something far stranger and more visceral.

Is Mexican Gothic worth reading?

Yes — especially if you like your horror gothic, atmospheric, and thematically rich. It won the Locus Award for Best Horror Novel and earned its bestseller status.

Fair warning on pacing: the first half is deliberately slow, all mood and mounting unease, and some readers stall before the reveal. A few also find Noemí's investigation relies on dreams and exposition more than detective work. But the final third is a genuinely wild payoff — inventive, grotesque, and unlike anything else in the gothic canon — and the book's critique of colonialism and eugenics gives the horror real weight. If you can savor a slow burn, it delivers.

Who it's for

Pick it up if

  • Fans of Rebecca, Jane Eyre, and classic gothic atmosphere
  • Readers who want horror rooted in real history and colonialism
  • Anyone who loves a glamorous, stubborn heroine in over her head
  • Body-horror fans willing to wait for a slow burn to ignite

Skip it if

  • You need fast pacing — the first half is deliberately languid
  • Mold, decay, and body horror make your skin crawl in the bad way
  • Dream sequences as a plot device tend to lose you
  • You're expecting folk horror about Mexican mythology — this is English gothic transplanted to Mexico

Is there a movie or show? READ IT BEFORE YOU WATCH IT

Not yet, but one has been in the works. A television adaptation of Mexican Gothic was announced at Hulu, with Kelly Ripa and Mark Consuelos's Milojo Productions attached and Silvia Moreno-Garcia involved. The project has been in development for years without a release date or casting news, so don't wait on it — the book stands entirely on its own, and reading it first is the safe bet.

If you liked this READ NEXT

1938 Rebecca R Daphne du Maurier
Gothic

Rebecca

by Daphne du Maurier

The template: a young woman, a brooding husband, and a house heavy with a dead wife's presence.

2022 The Hacienda H Isabel Cañas
Horror

The Hacienda

by Isabel Cañas

The natural next read — a haunted-house gothic set in post-independence Mexico.

2022 What Moves the Dead WM T. Kingfisher
Horror

What Moves the Dead

by T. Kingfisher

A retelling of Usher with a similar fascination for fungal, creeping wrongness.

Frequently asked questions

Is Mexican Gothic scary or just atmospheric?

Both, in sequence. The first two-thirds run on gothic dread — an oppressive house, disturbing dreams, a family that feels wrong — and the final third pivots into genuinely disturbing body horror. It's not a jump-scare book, but the imagery in the last act sticks with people.

Is Mexican Gothic part of a series?

No, it's a standalone novel with a complete ending. Silvia Moreno-Garcia writes in a different genre almost every book — if you want more of her horror, try The Daughter of Doctor Moreau or her noir-tinged work, but there's no sequel to Mexican Gothic.

What time period is Mexican Gothic set in?

The 1950s, mostly in the fictional mountain town of El Triunfo in Hidalgo, Mexico, at a decaying mansion called High Place built by an English mining family. The period setting matters: the book engages directly with eugenics, colonialism, and the real history of British silver mining in the region.

Do I need to know gothic classics to enjoy Mexican Gothic?

Not at all. The book nods to Rebecca, the Brontës, and Lovecraft, and readers who know those will catch extra resonances — but it's written to work completely on its own. Noemí is a modern, funny, sharp-tongued heroine, and the story explains everything it needs to.

A small, excellent email

One good book.
Every single week.

One good book in your inbox every week — picked like this one.